ANTHROPOLOGY 651 SEMINAR IN LINGUISTIC ANTHROPOLOGY Fall 1997
| Dr. Alexandra Jaffe |
T/R 2:30-3:45, College Hall 302 |
| Office Hours: Tues/Thurs 11-12 CH 311; Wed. 9-11 at
Hut |
|
| email: ajaffe@ocean.st.usm.edu |
|
| Phone 266-6193; Dept. Phone 266-4306 |
|
This seminar has several goals: 1) to give you a historical
perspective on the evolution of theory and practice in linguistic
anthropology; 2) to equip you with the analytical tools necessary to
read and be able to evaluate contemporary linguistic anthropology;
3) to make you aware of the role of language and linguistic
interpretation in the discipline of Anthropology in general and in
the practice of ethnographic fieldwork. The course does not presume
that you have extensive prior knowledge of linguistics or linguistic
anthropology; the nature and the volume of readings does assume that
you will take it upon yourself to do basic background reading in any
areas with which you have little familiarity. I have placed several
basic textbooks on Reserve for you with this in mind.
The first several weeks of the course will give you a foundation
in the concepts, terms and units of description of formal
linguistics, and will begin to orient you towards the
Anthropological perspective on the nature of meaning. The text we
are using is oriented towards the history of linguistic ideas and is
quite high-level; I will be filling in with the nuts and bolts of
linguistic description.
Required Texts:
McKay and Hornberger, Sociolinguistics and Language Teaching
Hanks, William, Language and Communicative Practices
Sontag, Susan, Illness as Metaphor/AIDS as Metaphor
Brice-Heath, Shirley, Ways With Words
Duranti, Alessandro, From Grammar to Consciousness
Rampton, Ben, Crossing Other readings in the syllabus
will be placed on Reserve.
Grading:
Midterm........................................................100
pts
Final (non cumulative)....................................100
pts
Term Paper...................................................150
pts
5-page essay.................................................50
pts
Attendance....................................................25
pts
Participation (oral and written).......................25 pts
2 précis (analytical summaries)@ 25 ea.........50 pts
TOTAL = 500 points
Calculation of final grade:
450-500= A; 400-449=B; 350-399=C; 300-349=D; 299 and below=F
As a general guideline, the term paper should be
approximately 20-30 pages in length. The length is less important
than the quality of the research and analysis involved. I will hand
out detailed guidelines on the term paper. You will be REQUIRED, as
part of the term paper grade, to hand in a proposal and a
preliminary bibliography. Failure to do so will result in point
loss. Moreover, if you do not take advantage of early advice from
me, you take a large risk that your final paper does not meet up to
my expectations. I will also accept and comment on paper drafts;
these must be turned in no later than 10 days before the final due
date so that I have time to read them and return them to you. The midterm
and final will be a combination of essay and short answer.
The 5 page essay will be on a topic of my choice. During the course
of the semester, you will be asked to write a précis
(analytical summary) of two recommended readings on the syllabus.
You will be asked (at least once) to report on your reading to the
class. I will distribute these assigments throughout the semester so
that we regularly have someone prepared to enrich the
discussion/lecture with a related reading. You may do an extra
précis for extra credit, or to raise your grade in that category. Attendance:
in a small seminar, attendance is crucial, not only for you, but for
the class as a whole. If you miss too many classes, I may lower your
grade in this category. Do not try to find out how many is too many.
Participation is also very important in a seminar. In
addition to your verbal contributions to the class, there will also
be periodic short written products included in this part of the
grade. For example, I may ask you to write the answer to a study
question on a particular reading on an index card to be turned in.
Or I may ask you to prepare a discussion question to be used in
class. Participation obviously implies preparation. There is little
room in this course for you to fall behind in your reading, and some
of the reading is quite difficult. I will help you (with
study/reading questions) to be efficient readers of this material. I
will also ask you to be active readers--you do not have to have had
a perfect grasp of a text to bring a good question to class. Having
said that you must be prepared, I recognize that everyone gets
swamped on occasion. Do not skip class if you have not done the
reading; let me know beforehand and I will not torment you with
questions. (Do not expect to do this often). Lateness/Academic
Honesty: Assignments are due on time. I subtract a letter grade
for each day late (a weekend is two days). Makeup exams are only
given for emergencies and are usually harder than the original one.
All of your work must be your own; be meticulous in your essays and
term paper about citing sources and you will not have any problems.
If you are not sure, ask me.
SCHEDULE OF READINGS
Readings in the book Sociolinguistics and Language Teaching
are followed by the abbreviation "SLT". Other readings are
in one of 4 places:
1) a packet under JAFFE ANT 651 (nothing follows reference
below)
2) a packet under JAFFE ANT 251"Packet B" (a "B"
is noted on the syllabus)
3) in a book on Reserve for this course ("Reserve" follows
book title)
4) in readily available bound periodicals in the stacks (recommended
readings). These are marked with a * and a full reference is
given.
| Week 1: |
Formal Models of Language |
| Tue. Aug. 26: |
Introduction to Course |
| Thu. Aug. 28: |
Hanks, Chapter 1 "Meaning and Matters of
Context"
Chapter 2 "The Language of Saussure" |
| |
|
| Week 2: |
|
| Tue. Sept. 2: |
Hanks Chapter 3 "From Signs to Sentences" (pp.
39-48) |
| Thu. Sept. 4: |
Hanks Chapter 4 "North American Formalism and the
Problem of Meaning" |
|
|
| Week 3: |
Language, Thought and Culture |
| Tue. Sept. 9: |
Hanks, Chapter 8 "Relativity, Reflexivity and
Difference" (pp. 169-84)
Boas, F. "Introduction to the Handbook of American Indian
Languages" (also in Blount,Language, Culture and
Society, on Reserve)
Whorf, B. "An American Indian Model of the Universe"
and "Language, Mind and Reality" pp. 257-268 |
| Thu. Sept. 11: |
Tan, Amy "The Language of Discretion" (B)
Hoijer, Harry "The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis (B) and in
Blount, below.
- Recommended readings on linguistic relativity:
Boas, Franz "On Alternating Sounds"
Whorf, B. "The Relation of Habitual Thought and
Behavior to Language" In Blount, ed. Language,
Culture and Society (on Reserve)
Sapir, E. "Language" in Blount, above.
*Conklin, H. (1973) "Color Categorization" American
Anthropologist 75(4):931-942.
*Hill and Mannheim (1992) Language and World View. Annual
Review of Anthropology.
|
|
|
| Week 4: |
Metaphor |
| Tue. Sept. 16: |
Basso, Keith "Wise Words of the Western Apache:
Metaphor and Semantic Theory" |
| Thu. Sept. 18: |
Hanks Chapter 11 "Communicative Practice in the
Corporeal Field"
Sontag, S. Illness as Metaphor |
|
|
| Week 5: |
|
| Tue. Sept. 23: |
Sontag, S. AIDS and its Metaphors
- Recommended readings on Metaphor:
Lakoff & Kovecses "The Cognitive Model of Anger
Inherent in American English" in Scott and Katz, Metaphor:
Implications and Applications (on Reserve)
Quinn, Naomi "The Cultural Basis of
Metaphor"
Fernandez,J. "The Mission of Metaphor in Expressive
Culture" in Persuasions and Performances (on
Reserve)
Nelson "Metaphor and the Media" (B)
Rose, Anne "Metaphors in Child Custody Mediation"
in Scott and Katz, above.
Banks &Thompson "Mental Models of the
Cardiovascular System" in Scott and Katz, above.
Sapir, J.D. "The Anatomy of Metaphor" in Sapir and
Crocker The Social Use of Metaphor (on Reserve)
Fill, Alvin "Ecolinguistics"
|
| Thu. Sept. 25: |
The Linguistic Philosophers/Speech Act Theory
Hanks Chapter 5 (91-102) |
|
|
| Week 6: |
|
| Tue. Sept. 30: |
Chick, J. "Intercultural Communication" Chapter 10
in SLT
Cohen, A. "Speech Acts" Chapter 12 in SLT.
- Recommended readings on Speech Acts:
Searle, J. "What is a Speech Act?" in Giglioli, Language
and Social Context (on Reserve)
Ervin Tripp, S. "Speech Acts and Social Learning"
in packet and in Basso & Shelby, Meaning in
Anthropology (Reserve)
Grice, H.P. "Meaning" In D. Steinberg and L
Jakobovis, Semantics: an Interdisciplinary Reader
(Reserve)
Levinson, S. Chapter 1 (p 1-53) in Pragmatics
(Reserve)
|
|
CONTEXT/Self/Interaction |
| Thu. Oct. 2: |
Hanks Chapter 7 "Saturation by Context"
Ochs, E. "Indexing Gender" in packet and in Duranti
and Goodwin, Rethinking Context (on Reserve) |
|
|
| Week 7: |
|
| Tue. Oct. 7: |
Duranti "Language in Context and Language as Context:
The Samoan Respect Vocabulary"
- Recommended Readings on Context:
*Eckert, P. and McConnell-Ginet, S. (1992) "Think
Practically and Look Locally: Language and Gender as
Community Based Practice" Annual Review of
Anthropology 21: 461-490.
Labov, W. "The Study of Language in its Social
Context" in Giglioli (book on Reserve)
|
| Thu. Oct. 9: |
The Ethnography of Communication
Saville-Troike "The Ethnography of Communication"
Chapter 11 in SLT. |
|
|
| Week 8: |
|
| Tue. Oct. 14: |
CHOOSE ONE:
Irvine "Strategies of Status Manipulation in the Wolof
Greeting" In Bauman and Sherzer, Explorations in the
Ethnography of Speaking (on Reserve)
Salmond "Rituals of Encounter Among the Maori" In
Bauman and Sherzer, above.
Milton "Meaning and Context: the Interpretation of
Greetings in Kasigau"
Kendall "Getting to Know You" (B)
CHOOSE ONE:
Barnes "Personal Names and Social
Classification"
Evans-Pritchard "Nuer Modes of Address"
Leeds-Hurwitz "Uncommon Forms of Address: A Business
Example"
Brown and Ford "Address in American English"
Brown and Gilman "The Pronouns of Power and
Solidarity" in Giglioli (book on Reserve) |
| Thu. Oct. 16 : |
MIDTERM EXAM |
|
|
| Week 9: |
Linguistic Variation: Sociolinguistic vs. Ethnographic
Approaches to "Speech Community" |
| Tue. Oct. 21: |
Hanks Chapter 9 "Beyond the Speaker and the Text"
(pp. 217-223)
Rickford "Regional and Social Variation" Chapter 5
in SLT (pp. 151-172) |
| Thu. Oct. 23: |
Freeman and McElhinny "Language and Gender"
Chapter 7 in SLT
- Recommended readings on Variation:
Nichols, P. "Pidgins and Creoles" Chapter 6 in SLT
McDavid, R. "Postvocalic -r in South Carolina: a Social
Analysis" (B)
Nichols, P. "Networks and Hierarchies"(B)
*Eckert, P. and McConnell-Ginet, S. : see above under
"context"
Keenan, Elinor "Norm-Makers, Norm Breakers: Uses of
Speech by Men and Women in a Malagasy Community" In
Bauman and Sherzer, (book on Reserve)
|
|
|
| Week 10: |
Language Socialization: Communicative Competence |
| Tue. Oct. 28: |
Harness-Goodwin, M. "Children's Linguistic and Social
Worlds" Anthropology Newsletter 38 (April
97):1,4-5.
Ochs and Schieffelin, "Language Acquisition and
Socialization: Three Developmental Stories" (B) |
| Thu. Oct. 30: |
Brice-Heath, Shirley Ways With Words, Prologue, Ch.
1-3 |
|
|
| Week 11: |
|
| Tue. Nov. 4: |
Ways With Words, Chapters 4 and 5
Rickford "Regional and Social Variants" section on
AAVE (pp. 172-185) |
| Thu. Nov. 6: |
Ways With Words, Chapters 6 and 7
McKay,S. "Literacy and Literacies" Chapter 13 in SLT.
Recommended Readings on Language Socialization: any chapter
from
Schieffelin and Ochs Language Socialization Across Cultures
(on Reserve) |
|
|
| Week 12: |
Performance, Narrative, Poetics |
| Tue. Nov. 11: |
Hanks Chapter 8, pp. 184-197.
Bauman, R. "Verbal Art as Performance" |
| Thu. Nov. 13: |
Hymes,D. "Ways of Speaking" in Bauman and Sherzer
(book on Reserve)
- CHOOSE ONE of the following:
Bauman, R. "Any Man Who Keeps More'n One Hound'll Lie
To You": A Contextual Study of Expressive Lying.
Johnstone,B. "Community and Contest: Midwestern Men and
Women Creating Their Worlds in Conversational
Storytelling."
- Recommended readings on Performance, Narrative,
Poetics:
*Bauman and Briggs (1990) "Poetics and Performance as
Critical Perspectives on Language and Social Life" Annual
Review of Anthropology.
Price, Laurie (1987) "Ecuadorian Illness Stories"
in Holland and Quinn Cultural Models in Language and
Thought (on Reserve)
Abrahams, R. "Complicity and Imitation in
Storytelling"
*Limon, José (1989) "Carne, Carnales and the
Carnivalesque: Bakhtinian Batos, Disorder and Narrative
Discourses" American Ethnologist 16:3.
|
|
|
| Week 13: |
Language and Political Economy |
| Tue. Nov. 18: |
Gal, Susan Language and Political Economy
also Annual Review of Anthropology 1989
Irvine, J. "When Talk Isn't Cheap: Language and Political
Economy"
also in American Ethnologist 16:248-67(1989) |
| Thu. Nov. 20: |
O'Barr& Conley "Ideological Dissonance in the
American Legal System" (B)
Mehan, H. "The Construction of an LD Student: A Case
Study in the Politics of Representation"
- Recommended Readings in Language and Political
Economy
Spedding, Alison "Open Castilian, Closed Aymara?
Bilingual Women in the Yungas of La Paz (Bolivia)
Stafford, S. "Language and Identity: Haitians in New
York City"
Urciuoli, Bonnie Chapter 4: Good English as Symbolic
Capital" in Exposing Prejudice: Puerto Rican
Experiences of Language, Race, and Class.
Gross, Joan (1993) "The Politics of Unofficial Language
Use: Walloon in Belgium, Tamazight in Morocco"
|
|
|
| Week 14: |
|
| Tue. Nov. 25: |
first half of Duranti From Grammar to Politics |
|
|
| Week 15: |
|
| Tue. Dec. 2: |
finish Duranti |
|
Language Ideology |
| Thu. Dec. 4: |
*Woolard & Schieffelin (1994) "Language
Ideology" Annual Review of Anthropology.
- Recommended Readings on Language Ideology
*Woolard, Kathryn (1985) Language Variation and Cultural
Hegemony: Toward an Integration of Sociolinguistic Theory
and Social Theory. American Ethnologist
12:738-748.
*Jaffe, Alexandra (1996) "The Second Annual Spelling
Contest: Orthography and Ideology." American
Ethnologist 23(4):1-21.
*Gal, Susan (1993) "Diversity and Contestation in
Linguistic Ideologies: German Speakers in Hungary." Language
in Society 22:337-359.
*Hill, Jane (1980) "Mixed Grammar, Purist Grammar and
Language Attitudes in Modern Nahuatl" Language in
Society 9:321-348.
Hill, Jane "Women's Speech in Modern Mexicano"
*Collins, James (1992) "Our Ideologies and Theirs"
Pragmatics (2)3: 405-415.
*Abu-Lughod, Lila (1990) "The Romance of Resistance:
Tracing Transformations of Power Through Bedouin Women"
American Ethnologist (17)1: 41-55.
|
|
|
| Week 16: |
Language Politics in Multilingual Contexts |
| Tue. Dec. 9: |
first part of Rampton, Crossing |
| Thu. Dec. 11: |
finish Rampton.
- Recommended Readings in Language Politics/Multilingual
contexts:
Heller, Monica "Ethnic Relations and Language Use in
Montreal"
Sridhar, K. "Societal Multilingualism" Chapter 2
in SLT.
Wiley, T. "Language Planning and Policy" Chapter 4
in SLT
*Hill, Jane (1985) "The Grammar of Consciousness and
the Consciousness of Grammar" American Ethnologist
12:4.
*Trosset, Carol (1986) "The Social Identity of Welsh
Learners" Language in Society 15: 165-192.
*Urciuoli, Bonnie (1995) Language and Borders. Annual
Review of Anthropology
|
Each syllabi the
intellectual property of the author. |